Advertisement

 
 
09 April 2008 @ 12:51 am
Torchwood Book: 'Trace Memory' Ramble  
Now that the season is over, I'm reading the books to help assuage the pains of withdrawal.

The review isn't very spoilery, but I do mention a few things I liked about the novel. I do not, however, give away the big reveal.

The general plot is very Torchwood-ish. In 1953, a crate being taken to the Torchwood Institute explodes, killing all but one dockworker named Michael Bellini. Fast forward 55 years later, Torchwood Three find a radioactive source in the Hub and discover Michael Bellini, completely unchanged. Turns out, Michael has begun to involuntarily time travel and has actually encountered each member of Torchwood Three at some point in their lives. So the question remains of what was inside the crate and why there are two mysterious men in bowler hats hunting Michael.

The entire thing read a little like The Time Traveler's Wife, but with less romance and more sci-fi. The biggest draw for me with this novel was that it did so well what the episode "Fragments" gave us. Mainly showing a glimpse into the lives of the team members before they became a part of Torchwood Three. In doing this you get some great additional information about everyone's characters and mindsets. But you also get a very sharp look at how much Torchwood took away from each of them.

One particular favorite was the look we got into Toshiko's life in Japan when she was a very small child. As expected, she was incredibly precocious, even at the age of 5 and I had a slight grin on my face at her enthusiasm for fairy tales. And her interactions with her entire family, but her father in particular sort of made me melancholy for how her life turned out to be so isolated as she got older and Torchwood pulled her further and further away from them. But her interactions with Michael are very adorable and I sort of squee that even as a kid, she was still so razor sharp and talented.

My other personal favorite was the look into Ianto Jones' first week at Torchwood One, where Michael ended up for a brief moment. Mainly because we finally get to meet Lisa before she became partially converted. For all the random insanity, danger and extraterrestrial lifeforms Torchwood deals with, I love how the base in London runs pretty much like any corporate office. Complete with water cooler gossip and days when the most one does is make up a very dull, budget spread sheet. You can read all of this with a slightly wincing eye as you realize that in a few short months, Ianto's relatively unremarkable life is all about to go to hell. His budding relationship with Lisa is so excruciatingly normal and sweet in how average it is that it kind of breaks your heart as you know how it all collapses in a huge ball of fire. Along with Lisa, there's the somewhat startling (at least for me) information that in London, Ianto lived in a flat with flat mates, got regular calls from his Mam back in Wales, and had friends outside of work. While this shouldn't be exactly a shocker, I guess I got so used to the notion of Ianto being so devoted and isolated by Torchwood Three that much like reading his relationship with Lisa with a knowledge of the future, it was sort of painful to read about the banality of his life as you know everything was going to change.

The same really goes for Owen and Tosh as well. There are a series of quick vignettes at the end of the book that show you what each team member does at the end of the case and each vignette is rather bittersweet. It's not so much that anyone is utterly crushed or emo-ing their hearts out about where their lives have gone, but you get a strong sense of how much damage and repair everyone has gone through over the years.

All in all, the plot and ultimate solutions weren't bad. But the real delights of this novel was getting more dimensions to everyone's characters.
 
 
( Post a new comment )
Rachel: JackHarknessReading[info]nilbywords on April 9th, 2008 09:51 pm (UTC)
I've read "Something in the Water" and "The Twilight Streets" so far and I have to say that I greatly enjoyed "Twilight Streets." Yes, don't fall over with shock. I have to applaud Gary Russell for fleshing out the Bilis Manger character and now I completely understand why you're so enthralled by him. It's also kind of amazing, but I think I prefer the Ianto in the books than the Ianto of the series, thus furthering your theory that it's GDL I can't stand, not the actual character.

Are you going to review the other ones? I know you've read them all, don't try and hide it.
(Reply) (Thread) (Link)
formerly lifeinsomniac: Torchwood[info]joonscribble on April 9th, 2008 11:34 pm (UTC)
I haven't read "Something in the Water" yet as I haven't been able to find a copy.

I'll probably say my bit about "The Twilight Streets" eventually, but I'm sort of saving it because I have a feeling my thoughts about it will leak into one of my fics and I'd hate to be redundant. Not so much the Bilis-thing but more the idea of Jack always being too late for...well, everything.
(Reply) (Parent) (Thread) (Link)
marvola: IantoFOOTR[info]marvola on April 15th, 2008 03:16 pm (UTC)
'Trace Memory' is my favourite out of all six books for the basic reasons you described. Ianto's section was truly heartbreaking to read when you know what followed. The most difficult bit was his desire to live in a nice apartment - something just so incredibly ordinary. As well as lying to his Mam about what he had for tea.

I think that story would have been amazing if they'd adapted it for the show.
(Reply) (Thread) (Link)
formerly lifeinsomniac[info]joonscribble on April 15th, 2008 06:42 pm (UTC)
The bit with him lying to his Mam about what he ate for tea depressed me so much more than it should have. There's something so young and sweet about it that it kind of tore at me that it was all going to change.

Setting that up against him at the end of the novel, quite contentedly watching James Bond films at the hub alone just added to it all.
(Reply) (Parent) (Thread) (Link)
(Anonymous) on April 16th, 2008 02:44 am (UTC)
Question
Your reviews just encouraged me to buy my own copies of both trace memory and twilight streets...the problem is I can't seem to find available copies in either barnes or borders...do you (or anyone who might read this post) know where I can get hold of one...am currently spending my vacation in minneapolis but i'll be travelling to san francisco in a week's time so any stores within these areas is fine with me...thank you....

bdw, if anyone is interested in helping me out this is my e-mail add: patcamique@yahoo.com...thank u!
(Reply) (Thread) (Link)
phineyj[info]phineyj on April 16th, 2008 08:20 pm (UTC)
Re: Question
I'm sure amazon.co.uk would send it to the States if you're desperate...I see amazon.com is saying there's a 1-2 month wait.
(Reply) (Parent) (Thread) (Link)
phineyj[info]phineyj on April 16th, 2008 08:19 pm (UTC)
I've just read it and I agree about the Ianto parts -- it was interesting to see his pre-series life and Lisa really came off the page as a believable character, even in the tiny amount of description. I thought the Jack characterisation was good too. In fact, I thought all the characterisations were well done. However, I'm afraid the plot left me cold. I thought it was ridiculous! (maybe it would have been okay on TV...the explosions would have distracted me from all the Bad Science).
(Reply) (Thread) (Link)
formerly lifeinsomniac[info]joonscribble on April 16th, 2008 08:22 pm (UTC)
I thought it was ridiculous! (maybe it would have been okay on TV...the explosions would have distracted me from all the Bad Science).

I'd long come to terms with the fact that Torchwood in both TV and book format would never give me a plot that could hold water. It's lie my brain had to recalibrate to the Bad Science setting so that I could just sit back and enjoy the characters.
(Reply) (Parent) (Thread) (Link)
 

Advertisement